Sandals Montego Bay Restaurant Reviews
There are 12 restaurants at Sandals Montego Bay offering a variety of cuisines from Asian to Italian to Caribbean. Below we have a full list, a link to menus and our overall impressions of each restaurant.
Getting the Best Deal at Sandals Montego Bay

After deciding on the resort, we booked our trip directly on Sandals.com. We always check for the weekly 777 deal before booking to save on our room rate or other promotions going on, which you can see here.
Alternatively, you can always contact us to help you book your trip to Sandals, making sure you get the best price possible.
Overall Thoughts on Sandals Montego Bay Dining
When we went to Sandals Montego Bay, we had some great gourmet dining experiences. In our opinion, one of Sandals Montego Bay best restaurants is Oleander. Not only is the food excellent, but you can also enjoy beautiful sunset views from the deck.
The menu has been updated and now features Caribbean cuisine. We loved being able to order multiple dishes (which you can do since it’s all included and unlimited!). Our two favorites were the Jerk Lobster Kebabs and the curried snapper. For dessert, we loved the Highgate Chocolate Marquise.
Other great Sandals Montego Bay restaurants we loved include the Soy sushi bar, Butch’s Chophouse for really high-quality steaks and seafood, and Tokyo Jo’s, where you can build your entree at the wok station.
Our favorite lunch dishes were hamburgers, quesadillas, fresh-baked pizzas, and jerk chicken.

Which Sandals Montego Bay Restaurant is Best?
Oleander
Our personal favorite is Oleader. Dine on delicious Caribbean cuisine overlooking the ocean from an elegant interior or covered deck. Offers wonderful sunset views. This is our top choice and we recommend ordering several dishes including the Blue Mountain Coffee Rub Strip Loin, Curried Chicken Kebabs, Appleton Creole Shrimp, Jerk Lobster Kebabs and the Highgate Chocolate Marquise.
Dress Code: Resort Evening Attire
Menu: Dinner
Dinner 5:30-9:30pm

Other Restaurants at Sandals Montego Bay
Bayside Brasserie
Bayside serves continental breakfast and buffet-style breakfast and lunch, then becomes an a la carte French restaurant for dinner. It has a beautiful outdoor deck overlooking the ocean.
This is a perfect place for breakfast and lunch for someplace quick. Bayside makes for a romantic dinner with sunset views.
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Breakfast, Lunch & Dinner
Continental Breakfast 5-7am
Breakfast 7:30-10:30am
Lunch 12:30-2:30pm
Dinner 5:30 to 10pm
Cucina Romana
Here we enjoyed Italian specialties with fabulous water views and a romantic ambiance. We recommend the Insalata con Mele Grana e Noci, Lasagna all’Emiliana and Filetto di Dentice.
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Dinner
Dinner 5:30-9:30pm
Tokyo Jo’s
This beachfront open-air restaurant was recently renovated and makes mouthwatering pan-Asian created right before your eyes. You choose the ingredients and a chef makes the stir fry right in front of you!
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Dinner
Hours: 5:30-10pm
Butch’s Steak & Seafood
A favorite among Sandals guest, Butch’s honors Sandals founder “Butch” Stewart and offers top quality grain-fed beef plus excellent fresh seafood. In the mornings you can also enjoy a la carte breakfast here as well. Reservations are required. Its hard to choose from the Chef’s Surf & Turf and the Lamb Chops, so I order the Surf & Turf with a side of lamb.
Dress Code: Resort Evening Attire
Hours: 8-11am, 5:30-9:30pm
Dino’s Pizzeria
This quick and casual restaurant serves fresh brick-oven pizza with traditional and unique toppings. My only complaint is that it isn’t open for longer hours.
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Lunch
Hours: 11am-6pm
The Mariner
This casual seaside bar and grill features fresh seafood, burgers, wraps, salads, and local dishes along with fantastic views. It reopens for late-night dishes as well in case you are hungry late at night.
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Lunch, Late Night
Hours: 11am-4pm, 10pm-5am
Café de Paris
Indulge in specialty coffees and a wide assortment of baked goods, pastries, and crepes at this Parisian patisserie. We go daily for coffee and regularly for crepes and ice cream!
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Snacks
Hours: 6:30am-10pm
The Jerk Shack
Famous for its delicious Caribbean jerk dishes, this casual open-air spot serves a variety of options just steps from the ocean. You need to go to the jerk shack at least once!
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Lunch
Hours: 11am-6pm
Soy Sushi Bar
Savor all kinds of sushi in sophisticated surroundings with indoor and outdoor dining. The appetizers and desserts are some of our favorite things to order like the Shrimp Tempura, Crispy Octopus Takoyaki and Kanten Sushi Roll.
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Dinner
Hours: 5:30-9:30pm
The Cricketer’s Pint
This authentic British pub has a full bar as well as a great menu of pub fare and desserts in a fun atmosphere. I recommend the Chicken Wings and Chicken Masala.
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Menu: Dinner
Hours: 4pm-10pm
Stew Fish
At Stew Fish, they serve authentic Caribbean with your toes in the sand at this casual beachfront restaurant.
Dress Code: Resort Casual
Hours: serves dinner but currently closed for maintenance

A huge plus to Sandals Montego Bay is that you also get access to all the restaurants at nearby Sandals Royal Caribbean (which you can get to via a free shuttle). There are 9 restaurants there including two of our all-time favorites: Royal Thai, which is on the private island and offers a really fun experience in addition to amazing food, and Bombay Indian. Other restaurants at Sandals Royal Caribbean are Spices (Caribbean), La Tavola (Italian), Le Jardinier (French), The Mariner (seaside grill), The Jerk Shack (Jamaican), Bella Napoli (pizza), and The Cricketer’s Pint (British)

Sandals Montego Bay Restaurants Dress Code
There are two dress codes at Sandals restaurants: resort casual and resort evening attire.
Resort casual includes shorts, jeans, casual pants like khakis, t-shirts, and polo shirts. You must wear both shirts and shoes in all restaurants. Flipflops and sandals are fine. Bathing suits must be covered up.
For resort evening attire, men need to wear dress pants or nice jeans and long or short-sleeved dress shirts, with or without a collar—no t-shirts or sleeveless shirts. Hats are not allowed, and shoes must be nicer closed-toe shoes. Women can wear dress pants, nice jeans, or skirts with a nice top, or dresses. Shoes should be nice sandals or heels—no flipflops or sneakers.
Only two restaurants at Sandals Montego Bay require Resort Evening Attire: Butch’s and Oleander.
Do Sandals Montego Bay Restaurants Require Reservations?
There is just one restaurant at Sandals Montego Bay that requires reservations: Butch’s Steak & Seafood. All the others do not need reservations, so you can dine at whatever time is best for you.
Which Sandals Montego Bay Restaurants Serve Breakfast?
You can get continental or buffet breakfast at Bayside, a la carte breakfast at Butch’s, and coffee, pastries, and crepes at Café de Paris.
Are There Quick Service Restaurants at Sandals Montego Bay?
Yes, you have several options at Sandals Montego Bay if you want to grab a quick bite to eat. These include The Jerk Shack, Dino’s Pizzeria, and Café de Paris.